CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.0 Introductions
This section will include; Village banking on outreach maximization of MFs, Benefits of individual banking on outreach maximization of MFs and Challenges of Group lending on outreach maximization on MFIs.
2.1 Village banking on outreach maximization of MFIs
Village banks help in training of the locals on the different ways of managing their business. This is mainly in areas like financial management, which involves all the activities like monitoring, control, budgeting and evaluation that enable an enterprise to obtain capital for growth, allocate resources efficiently, maximize the income potential of the business activity and monitor results through accounting documents. Such management requires a well-written, comprehensive financial management plan clearly outlining the assets, debts and the current and future profit potential of the enterprise (Ayyagari, Demirguc-Kunt and Maksimovic, 2011).
Village banking training enables the people in rural areas to have their savings kept, most of the village banking institutions in the villages include SACCOS that are formed by any group of people who either have common bond (like in the case of one employer), or people with similar objectives. Examples of such people are Government employees, employees of government parastatals, teachers, nurses, doctors, traders, mall workers, municipal workers, tax workers, employees of private commercial companies, parliamentarians, hawkers and domestic workers. This helps microfinance institutions to be in position to develop the local p[eople by offering small credit facilities to the people in villages (Beck & Cull, 2014).
Village banking unites people in groups this helps the people in village to share information and learn from one another this teaches people to have the ability to be in position to have better financial management amongst them selves as stated by Boah, (2010) defines (financial control) as the process of regulating an organization’s financial resources and activities such that actual performance conforms to the standards set. Koontz and Heinz (2013), argues that the task of control is to make plans succeed; and normally control must reflect plans, and planning precedes control. They further observe that a budget is a widely used device for managerial control, and argue that budgeting is the formulation of plans for a given future period in numerical terms. Mohsin (2002), also assert that financial control must complement financial planning, and that the control function is composed of four distinct phases i.e. determination of operational standards, evaluation of the enterprise progress in relation to pre-determined standards, investigation of organization financial function and taking corrective action in event of deviation, and lastly follow up actions by the executive personnel to ascertain whether corrective actions are effective.
Microfinance institution enhances the capacity of villagers to be in position to borrow money and also grow their business, According to (Papp et al., (2009) due to limited capacity of villagers to build strong sustainable business village banks provides to villagers the loans at low interest rates which is affordable this helps in enabling the village people to set up the business which helps them in achieving their growth and development.
Village banks help in enabling Improvement of business by the village people this helps the village people to develop their business; (Suryadevara, (2017) indicates that the use of village has helped many village people to fund some few infrastructural developments in the village like constructing the village wells and village roads. The current limited supply of these resources limits operations and drives up cost for some of the business this affects the village organizations.
Improving on the level of funding, The key challenges confronting the microfinance institutions in developing countries such as Ghana include Inadequate funding for capacity building, inadequate and expensive infrastructure base, Inadequate credit delivery and management, the inability to target the vulnerable and the marginalized, information gathering and dissemination, regulation and supervision, consumer protection and research, monitoring and evaluation (Marital, 2012).
Armendariz et al, (2010) stated that the information asymmetry problems could potentially be eliminated if lenders had cheap ways to gather and evaluate information on their clients and to enforce contracts. However, lenders typically face relatively high transactions costs when working in poor communities since handling many small transactions is far more expensive than servicing one large transaction for a richer borrower. Another potential solution would be available if borrowers had marketable assets to offer as collateral. In this sense, any problem on the loan was covered by the borrower’s asset.
Thus, the lender could lend without risk. But the starting point for microfinance is that new ways of delivering loans are needed precisely because borrowers are too poor to have much in the way of marketable assets. However, (Datta, 2010) stated that one way for the government to improve enforcement conditions for credit markets is to improve the possibilities for usable sources of collateral like implementation of land registration.
Inadequate Credit delivery and management, the mechanism for credit delivery within the microfinance sector is inadequate and the microfinance institutions do not have the expertise to categorize their client into the various poverty categories so as to meet their specific needs. (NBE, 2010).
Regulation and Supervision Microfinance institutions in the formal sector operates within a rigid regulatory and supervisory environment which presents some challenges for innovation, outreach and overall performance of the institutions. There is also an absence of specific BoG regulatory guidelines for the apex bodies in the semi-formal and informal sectors for the supervision of their members, (Fosu, 2013).
Better information gathering and Dissemination, Lack of adequate and reliable information remains a challenge to the microfinance industry. These problems adversely affect the ability to properly target the right clients in order to meet the specific needs of such clients. There is also a paucity of information on microfinance institutions and their operations (Naidu & Chand, 2012).
Creation of better ways of generation of information from lenders, Karlan & Zinman (2006) stated that better understandings of information asymmetries are critical for both lenders and policymakers. For instance, adverse selection problems should motivate policymakers and lenders to consider subsidies, loan guarantees, information coordination, and enhanced screening strategies. On the other hand, moral hazard problems should also motivate policymakers and lenders to consider legal reforms in the areas of liability and enhanced dynamic contracting schemes.
2.2 Benefits of individual banking on outreach maximization of MFs
Lending to individuals enables the low income earners to be in position to have complete control over their business. This is because when someone borrows they are able to maintain complete control over their business this motivates the entrepreneurs to be in position to create their business without having to share it with lenders. This according to Thassanabanjong et al., (2009) the lender charges a company interest for the use of a loan, but the lender does not have the right to say how a company should manage its business. The ownership of the business stays completely in the hands of the corporate directors and shareholders. This also means that lenders will not be entitled to any of the profits that companies make from the business; the borrowing company is merely required to repay the loan within the fixed time period.
Individual lending enables the organization to improve none its performance because it is able to purchase the necessary machinery and materials needed in the development of the organization. Cecchetti et al. (2011) observe that a reasonable debt level improves welfare and enhances growth but high level debts can lead to a decline in growth of a firm. On the same note Reinhart et al. (2009) reinforces this assertion by arguing that debt impacts positively to the growth of a firm only when it is within certain levels. He opines that a firm becomes vulnerable to financial crisis when the ratio goes beyond certain levels, while one the same view Cecchetti et al. (2011) contends that over borrowing by a firm can cause bankruptcy and financial ruin. Accumulating high levels of debt by a small scale enterprise will constrain its ability to undertake project that are likely to be profitable, however it also helps the business to retain its autonomy.
Individual lending enables the business to be in position to have a proper decision making to eliminate chances of failure. When an individual gets a loan as a single person he is able to make quick decisions which helps in the elimination of bureaucratic tendencies that are popular with group lending where decision making is difficult. For an individual entrepreneur he is able to choose the right credit and interest and what to do the with the funds he get from the business without wasting time.
Individual lending is appropriate for companies which pursue an aggressive growth strategy, especially when they have access to low interest rates. Though a company may lose some of its assets if it is unable to repay its loans, the company won’t lose corporate control or ownership to outsiders. Companies wishing to make use of debt financing are recommended to seek appropriate legal advice from the company’s lawyers and accountants for better information on asset protection Boah, (2010).
Through individual lending companies are able to maintain a certain amount of liquidity which helps them to plan easily on repaying back the credit. The interest rate which a company pays is usually based on the prime interest rate, and the interest that the company has to pay on a company loan is tax-deductible. This means that debt financing covers up part of a company’s business income from taxes and reduces the company’s tax liability Soumadi & Hayajneh (2012) . A study by Ahmad et al.(2012) in Malaysia which sought to investigate how capital structure impacts on a firm’s performance by analyzing the relationship between return on assets (ROA), return on equity (ROE) and short-term debt and total debt established that short-term debt and long-term debt had significant relationship with ROA.
Credit helps the organization to be able to improve on its cash management policies which helps it to improve on its performance. Cash management may be defined as an activity at serving the dual purpose of increasing sales revenue by extending credit to customers who are deemed a good credit risk and minimizing risk loss from bad debts by restricting or denying credit to customers who are not good credit risk. It is also directly related to operation, quality, sales and the effectiveness of credit control lies in procedures employed for judging a prospect’s creditworthiness, rather than in procedures used in extracting the owed money also called credit management (Keneth, 2004).
Credit enables the business organization to be able to build a good Character, which improves on managerial performance. This evaluates the applicants’ traits to analyze the willingness to meet the credit obligations. (Kakuru, 2000) highlighted the following variables to consider when analyzing applicant’s character. This is done considering the applicant’s banking behavior from the bank records, the level of education, mental status, operation stability, contact, attachment to government agencies and the previous dealing with bank. This is done to ascertain the applicant’s honesty.
Individual lending enables the maintenance of ownership by the organization this helps in the proper management of the organization’s resources and eliminating the key challenges that may be as a result of cash by the organization. The benefit of maintaining ownership is that management has complete control over the decisions made on behalf of the company. Management also has the ability to choose its own board members. The only obligation a debtor has to a lender is to pay back the principal and interest. When the business pays back its loan in full it maintains ownership of its business (Marital, 2012).
Tax benefits are received by the organization, another advantage of Credit is that companies receive tax deductions for the interest paid on debt. In most cases, the Internal Revenue Service considers the interest paid a business expense and allows businesses to deduct the payments from their corporate income taxes. This is beneficial for businesses because it allows them to use the money saved to grow the business (Fosu, 2013).
Achievement of greater financial freedom, Businesses using Credit to raise capital have more flexibility than those using equity financing because they are only obligated to the investor or lender for the repayment period. After all money is paid back, the business is completely free from its obligation. Companies also have greater flexibility because the paperwork to obtain debt financing is less complicated and less expensive than equity financing of (Thevaruban, 2009).
Credit rating, another disadvantage is that Credit affects the credit rating of a business. A company that has a significantly greater amount of debt than equity financing is considered risky. A company with a lower credit rating that issues bonds typically will have to pay a higher interest rate to attract investors. Companies who have to pay more in interest may experience a cash flow problem in the future (Suwastika & Anand, 2012).
Cash qualifications, Companies seeking debt financing must meet the lender’s cash requirement, which means companies must have sufficient cash on hand. This is difficult for businesses depending on debt financing for a cash infusion. Some companies may have to put up collateral to qualify for financing, which puts assets at risk if they fail to repay the debt (Datta, 2010).
It improves on the capacity of the organization; this evaluates the applicants’ ability to pay the debt when advanced in the required period. This is ascertained by evaluating the value of customer’s capital and asset offered as collateral against the loan. This may be judged by assessing the customers’ capital and assets which may act as security.
2.3 Challenges of Group lending on outreach maximization on MFIs
Most of the credit institutions offering group lending services charge high interest rates this affects the ability of the business to be in position to grow since high interest rates affects the profitability and productivity of the business in line with Kikonyogo (2010) further asserts that interest rate is the percent charged or paid for the use of money. It is charged when the money is being borrowed and paid when it is being loaned; in group lending organizations charge high interest rates because the credit given is normally of low interest rates.
One of the principal challenges of group lending is providing loans at affordable interest rates. The global average interest and fee rate is estimated at 37%, with rates reaching as high as 70% in some markets (Helms, 2006). Helms (2006) further states that the reason for the high interest rates is not primarily cost of capital but rather, the main reason for the high cost of microfinance loans is the high transaction cost of traditional microfinance operations relative to loan size. Microfinance institutions offer small loans at high administrative costs this forces them to charge high interest rates because of the cost maintaining the staff.
Difficulty in obtaining security for the group loans; Most of the group lending organizations are made up of small scale business entrepreneurs who don’t have adequate security to guarantee loan acquisition. According to a study in Bangladesh most of the poor people in group lending scheme do not have adequate security for ht loan. This has however led to high to the lending institutions as some times borrowers are reluctant to pay back the loan they took this affects the ability of the lending institution to continue giving out credit because of the risks involved in group lending (Kauffmann, 2015).
According to Kikonyogo (2000), group lending has challenges of mistrust among the members this affects the credit worthiness of the staff. This affects the ability of the MFIs to be able to provide credit to the members of the organization. When member begin to mistrust themselves about the payment of the loan services they develop negative attitude towards themselves this affects their ability to provide credit.
Access to loan facilities is so crucial to the performance of the group of organi Small business in Uganda can rarely meet the conditions set by micro financial institutions, which see small enterprises as a risk because of poor guarantees and lack of information about their ability to repay loans. Therefore, improving business conditions, boosting the capacity of small enterprises, expanding the financial sector and strengthening links between firms will permanently increase small enterprises’ access to finance.
It is generally acknowledged that the ability of small enterprises and rural households to invest for the long term and make calculated decisions for risky income flows is partly shaped by microfinance institutions and the services they offer (Ocaya,2002). Ocaya still says that despite some development in this service sector, in Uganda the majority of the small enterprises remain without access to the credit services they need to compete in the market and to improve their livelihoods.
Lack of affordable Voluntary savings products to the group lenders. Most of the voluntary saving products are expensive this affects the ability of the group members to be in position to lend money to the members. Some microfinance institution design a condition of voluntary saving products were by members have to first deposit saving before they are given loans. This affects the ability of the group members to be in position to get loans in case one of the members is not able to afford the necessary saving required, (Kauffmann, 2005).
Limited resources by most of the group members affect the ability of the organization to be in position to acquire credit Hill, (2011) some of the group members may not be in position to have the collateral security required to get a loan this affects the performance of the organization which inhibits
Poor Infrastructure especially in developing countries affects the ability of group lending organizations Kikonyogo (2010) while the economic policy debate has gone through cycles of arguing for and against state intervention, further argues that the private sector can participate in making the infrastructure effective, but its regulation is above all a state function. The importance of this function has increased in recent years, because of the changing nature of competition in regional and global markets.
Unfavorable laws regarding the group lending systems has affected the ability of the group lending organizations. Most of the microfinance institutions have conditions which must be first fulfilled by the members in the group before they can receive loans some of them include having an account number and paying member subscription fees this affects the ability of the organization to be in position to get loans.
Lack of proper legal systems concerning the group lending scheme has affected the ability of microfinance institutions to be in position to recover this therefore has made microfinance institutions to put in strict rules concerning the acquisition of the loans by the group members. According to study in Kenya there is a proper government rule governing the group lending scheme.
Poor government policies regarding the group lending scheme; most government in sub-Saharan African do not clear policies regarding the management of group lending this lack of a clear comprehensive policy this is in line with Richards (2010), proper government administration in regard to policies is key for the better performance of groups in the lending is essential since it facilitates good policy formulation and implementation.
David, (2011) In many developing countries, bureaucracy has displayed a high degree of centralization of resources and decision-making. Initiatives by local authorities to promote micro finance activities are often stifled by a centralized decision-making process and lack of financial resources at the local level.